Location-based Scope 2 values your electricity at the average emissions of the grid you draw from; market-based values it by the specific contracts you hold — renewable energy certificates, PPAs, or a supplier tariff. Under the GHG Protocol, Thai companies with such contracts should report both. The two numbers can differ sharply.
- What is the difference between location-based and market-based Scope 2?
- Which method should a Thai company use — or must you report both?
- How does the location-based method work in Thailand?
- What counts for the market-based method?
- How do the two methods affect your FTSE and IFRS S2 disclosure?
- How should you set up Scope 2 accounting?
What is the difference between location-based and market-based Scope 2?
Scope 2 covers indirect emissions from the electricity, steam, heat, and cooling you buy. The GHG Protocol Scope 2 Guidance defines two accounting methods for it:
- Location-based — reflects the average emission intensity of the grid where your consumption physically happens. It ignores any contracts; it simply asks how carbon-intensive the grid you sit on is.
- Market-based — reflects the electricity you have chosen through contractual instruments: renewable energy certificates, power purchase agreements (PPAs), or a specific supplier tariff. Where you have no such contract, a residual-mix or grid factor applies.
The same kilowatt-hour can therefore carry two different emission figures depending on the method — which is exactly why the Protocol treats them as complementary, not as alternatives.
| Dimension | Location-based | Market-based |
|---|---|---|
| What it reflects | The physical grid you draw from | The contracts and instruments you hold |
| Emission factor | National grid average (TGO) | I-REC / PPA / supplier; residual or grid factor if none |
| Thai data source | TGO grid electricity factor | I-RECs via EGAT, TIGRs, PPAs |
| Lowered by | The grid decarbonising over time | Buying RECs or signing renewable PPAs |
| When required | Always | Whenever you hold contractual instruments (dual report) |
Under the GHG Protocol, Thai companies with such contracts should report both.
Scope 2 Accounting: Location-Based vs Market-Based for Thai Companies
Which method should a Thai company use — or must you report both?
If you hold any contractual instruments — an I-REC purchase, a solar PPA, a green tariff — the GHG Protocol’s dual reporting requirement applies: you disclose Scope 2 both location-based and market-based. This stops a company from claiming a clean market-based number while hiding the fact that it still draws physically from a fossil-heavy grid. Investors, CDP, RE100, and science-based targets all expect to see both figures. The gap between them is revealing: a wide spread signals heavy reliance on certificates over a still-fossil grid, and sophisticated reviewers will probe it.
If you hold no contractual instruments at all, you report the location-based figure and note that the market-based method is not yet applicable.
How does the location-based method work in Thailand?
For location-based Scope 2, Thai organisations apply the national grid electricity emission factor published by TGO (องค์การบริหารจัดการก๊าซเรือนกระจก). It represents the average carbon intensity of the Thai grid mix. Two practical points:
- Use the correct, current factor version and record it — verifiers check this.
- The figure falls only as the national grid itself decarbonises; nothing you buy changes your location-based number.
- TGO updates the grid factor periodically, so revisit your comparatives whenever the published value changes.
Because the location-based method is always required, it is the floor of any credible Scope 2 disclosure.
What counts for the market-based method?
The market-based method lets your renewable procurement show up in your accounts — but only if the instruments meet the GHG Protocol Scope 2 Quality Criteria. In Thailand the main instruments are International RECs (I-RECs), issued through EGAT as the accredited local issuer, TIGRs, and PPAs. To count, an instrument should:
- Convey the renewable attribute and be claimed only once (retired or redeemed on your behalf).
- Be sourced from the same market or grid where you consume.
- Be as close as possible to your consumption period (vintage matched).
- Be tracked, unique, and free of double counting.
Thailand does not yet publish an official residual-mix factor, so companies without instruments typically apply the grid-average factor for the market-based figure and disclose that limitation. Keep the certificates and PPA records — they are part of your audit trail. Remember, too, that buying certificates lowers only your market-based figure: RE100 and CDP read that number, but your physical, location-based emissions are unchanged.
How do the two methods affect your FTSE and IFRS S2 disclosure?
Getting Scope 2 right is a disclosure-quality issue, not just an accounting one. As the comparison above shows, the two methods can tell very different stories about the same building, so reviewers want both — clearly labelled and consistently applied year to year. FTSE Russell rewards transparent, complete disclosure from 2026, and IFRS S2 — via the Thai Sustainability Reporting Standards, phasing in from SET50 in 2027 — expects Scope 2 reported on a clear, consistent basis. A system that computes both methods from the same activity data, and keeps the certificate evidence, makes this straightforward: carbon measurement powered by KClimate, delivered by Othello. See the carbon accounting platform, the full measure-to-disclose path, and where you stand on the Thailand FTSE Readiness Index.
How should you set up Scope 2 accounting?
Build for dual reporting from the outset:
- Meter and record electricity consumption by site, in consistent units.
- Apply the current TGO grid factor for the location-based figure.
- Log every I-REC, TIGR, and PPA, with vintage and retirement evidence, for the market-based figure.
- Report both numbers, clearly labelled, in your disclosure.
- Reconcile market-based claims to retired certificates so a verifier can follow them.
Done well, Scope 2 becomes a place to show genuine renewable progress rather than a source of awkward questions. Add the TGO CFO discipline and bilingual English disclosure, and both numbers stand up to scrutiny. To set up location- and market-based Scope 2 the right way, book a call with Othello.
Turn your carbon numbers into a scored disclosure
We build TGO-certified CFO/CFP footprints and convert them into the FTSE-legible English climate disclosure that raters actually read.
See where your English edition is losing FTSE points.
A free Gap Audit maps your published English disclosure against FTSE Russell’s 14 themes — and shows exactly which gaps are quietly costing you points, index inclusion and investor attention.



