Bench active · EN ↔ TH · TEL +66 02-859-2145 · NDA from first email · 1-hour quote SLA
EN TH
Request a Proposal

Scope 2 Accounting: Location-Based vs Market-Based for Thai Companies

Location-based Scope 2 values your electricity at the average emissions of the grid you draw from; market-based values it by the specific contracts you hold — renewable energy certificates, PPAs, or a supplier tariff. Under the GHG Protocol, Thai companies with such contracts should report both. The two numbers can differ sharply.

What is the difference between location-based and market-based Scope 2?

Scope 2 covers indirect emissions from the electricity, steam, heat, and cooling you buy. The GHG Protocol Scope 2 Guidance defines two accounting methods for it:

  • Location-based — reflects the average emission intensity of the grid where your consumption physically happens. It ignores any contracts; it simply asks how carbon-intensive the grid you sit on is.
  • Market-based — reflects the electricity you have chosen through contractual instruments: renewable energy certificates, power purchase agreements (PPAs), or a specific supplier tariff. Where you have no such contract, a residual-mix or grid factor applies.

The same kilowatt-hour can therefore carry two different emission figures depending on the method — which is exactly why the Protocol treats them as complementary, not as alternatives.

Dimension Location-based Market-based
What it reflects The physical grid you draw from The contracts and instruments you hold
Emission factor National grid average (TGO) I-REC / PPA / supplier; residual or grid factor if none
Thai data source TGO grid electricity factor I-RECs via EGAT, TIGRs, PPAs
Lowered by The grid decarbonising over time Buying RECs or signing renewable PPAs
When required Always Whenever you hold contractual instruments (dual report)

Under the GHG Protocol, Thai companies with such contracts should report both.

Scope 2 Accounting: Location-Based vs Market-Based for Thai Companies

Which method should a Thai company use — or must you report both?

If you hold any contractual instruments — an I-REC purchase, a solar PPA, a green tariff — the GHG Protocol’s dual reporting requirement applies: you disclose Scope 2 both location-based and market-based. This stops a company from claiming a clean market-based number while hiding the fact that it still draws physically from a fossil-heavy grid. Investors, CDP, RE100, and science-based targets all expect to see both figures. The gap between them is revealing: a wide spread signals heavy reliance on certificates over a still-fossil grid, and sophisticated reviewers will probe it.

If you hold no contractual instruments at all, you report the location-based figure and note that the market-based method is not yet applicable.

How does the location-based method work in Thailand?

For location-based Scope 2, Thai organisations apply the national grid electricity emission factor published by TGO (องค์การบริหารจัดการก๊าซเรือนกระจก). It represents the average carbon intensity of the Thai grid mix. Two practical points:

  • Use the correct, current factor version and record it — verifiers check this.
  • The figure falls only as the national grid itself decarbonises; nothing you buy changes your location-based number.
  • TGO updates the grid factor periodically, so revisit your comparatives whenever the published value changes.

Because the location-based method is always required, it is the floor of any credible Scope 2 disclosure.

What counts for the market-based method?

The market-based method lets your renewable procurement show up in your accounts — but only if the instruments meet the GHG Protocol Scope 2 Quality Criteria. In Thailand the main instruments are International RECs (I-RECs), issued through EGAT as the accredited local issuer, TIGRs, and PPAs. To count, an instrument should:

  • Convey the renewable attribute and be claimed only once (retired or redeemed on your behalf).
  • Be sourced from the same market or grid where you consume.
  • Be as close as possible to your consumption period (vintage matched).
  • Be tracked, unique, and free of double counting.

Thailand does not yet publish an official residual-mix factor, so companies without instruments typically apply the grid-average factor for the market-based figure and disclose that limitation. Keep the certificates and PPA records — they are part of your audit trail. Remember, too, that buying certificates lowers only your market-based figure: RE100 and CDP read that number, but your physical, location-based emissions are unchanged.

How do the two methods affect your FTSE and IFRS S2 disclosure?

Getting Scope 2 right is a disclosure-quality issue, not just an accounting one. As the comparison above shows, the two methods can tell very different stories about the same building, so reviewers want both — clearly labelled and consistently applied year to year. FTSE Russell rewards transparent, complete disclosure from 2026, and IFRS S2 — via the Thai Sustainability Reporting Standards, phasing in from SET50 in 2027 — expects Scope 2 reported on a clear, consistent basis. A system that computes both methods from the same activity data, and keeps the certificate evidence, makes this straightforward: carbon measurement powered by KClimate, delivered by Othello. See the carbon accounting platform, the full measure-to-disclose path, and where you stand on the Thailand FTSE Readiness Index.

How should you set up Scope 2 accounting?

Build for dual reporting from the outset:

  1. Meter and record electricity consumption by site, in consistent units.
  2. Apply the current TGO grid factor for the location-based figure.
  3. Log every I-REC, TIGR, and PPA, with vintage and retirement evidence, for the market-based figure.
  4. Report both numbers, clearly labelled, in your disclosure.
  5. Reconcile market-based claims to retired certificates so a verifier can follow them.

Done well, Scope 2 becomes a place to show genuine renewable progress rather than a source of awkward questions. Add the TGO CFO discipline and bilingual English disclosure, and both numbers stand up to scrutiny. To set up location- and market-based Scope 2 the right way, book a call with Othello.

Turn your carbon numbers into a scored disclosure

We build TGO-certified CFO/CFP footprints and convert them into the FTSE-legible English climate disclosure that raters actually read.

TGO CFO & CFP

Before your next disclosure cycle

See where your English edition is losing FTSE points.

A free Gap Audit maps your published English disclosure against FTSE Russell’s 14 themes — and shows exactly which gaps are quietly costing you points, index inclusion and investor attention.

ISO 17100 · NDA from the first email · 100% in-house Bangkok bench
Facebook
Twitter
LinkedIn
WhatsApp
Get Free Quote

Answers

Frequently asked questions

What is the difference between location-based and market-based Scope 2 accounting?
Location-based Scope 2 reflects the average emissions intensity of the electricity grid where consumption occurs, using a national or regional grid emission factor. Market-based Scope 2 reflects the emissions from the electricity a company has specifically chosen or contracted, such as through renewable energy certificates or power purchase agreements. The GHG Protocol asks companies to report both, which is why Thai disclosers increasingly present the two figures side by side.
Which Scope 2 method should a Thai listed company use for its disclosure?
Under the GHG Protocol Scope 2 Guidance, companies operating in markets with instruments such as renewable energy certificates are expected to report both a location-based and a market-based figure. For most Thai companies this means applying the national grid emission factor for the location-based number and reflecting any renewable procurement in the market-based number. Othello helps companies present both figures clearly and consistently in English and Thai so they read cleanly to FTSE Russell and other reviewers.
Where does Thailand's grid emission factor come from for Scope 2 calculations?
The grid emission factor used for location-based Scope 2 in Thailand is typically the national factor published by the Thailand Greenhouse Gas Management Organization (TGO), which Thai carbon footprint reports rely on. Companies should state which factor and vintage they applied so reviewers can follow the calculation. Othello supports organizational carbon footprint work across Scopes 1, 2 and 3 and documents the factors used for transparency.
FTSE 2026 PlaybooksFree ESG disclosure guides
Chat on LINEแอดไลน์ · ตอบใน 1 ชม.
Add Othello ESG on LINE (QR code)
แอดไลน์ · Add us on LINE
Scan to chat with Othello ESG on LINE — a reply within one business hour, under NDA from the first message.
Open LINE →
Recognised & delivered Credited in DLA Piper × UK PACT × DCCE’s carbon-pricing report · SET JUMP+ Advisory Pool listed advisor · FTSE Russell 4.0/5.0 delivered · ISO 17100 certified
Get a 1-hour quote →

Research & Reports

Free Tools

ISSB Training

· YouTube
Free tools & research State of ESG Disclosure· ESG Rating Check· FTSE 2026 Playbooks· Regulation Radar· Greenwashing Checker