Bench active · EN ↔ TH · TEL +66 02-859-2145 · NDA from first email · 1-hour quote SLA
EN TH
Request a Proposal

Carbon Is Now a Trade Cost: CBAM’s Paid Phase, Verified Emissions, and Your FTSE Score

On 1 January 2026 the EU’s Carbon Border Adjustment Mechanism left its reporting-only phase behind. After more than two years of transitional filings that ran from October 2023, importers now have to buy and surrender CBAM certificates against the embedded emissions of the cement, fertiliser, iron and steel, aluminium, hydrogen and electricity they bring into the European Union. The paperwork became a price.

For Thailand, the number attached to that shift is now concrete. Research from the Kasikorn Research Centre puts the initial impact at roughly ฿28 billion — about 3.8% of Thailand’s total exports to the EU — with steel and aluminium producers carrying the heaviest load.

What most Thai boards are still underestimating is not the carbon price itself. It is the evidentiary standard sitting underneath it — and the fact that the very same emissions numbers are, from this year, also being read by FTSE Russell out of your English disclosure.

฿28bn
estimated initial CBAM cost to Thai exports
3.8%
of Thailand’s total exports to the EU
+10%
punitive markup on default values in 2026
€100/t
penalty for inaccurate or missing declarations

Carbon stopped being an environmental line item

The framing shift matters as much as the cost. Speaking for the Steel Industry Group at the Federation of Thai Industries, chairman Bantoon Juicharern put the change in plain commercial terms:

Carbon will no longer be only an environmental issue. It will become an unavoidable trade cost.

Bantoon Juicharern, Chairman, Steel Industry Group · Federation of Thai Industries

That sentence relocates carbon accounting out of the sustainability department and into cost of goods sold. A tonne of embedded CO₂e that cannot be evidenced is no longer a disclosure weakness — it is a margin leak at the border, repeated on every shipment, for the life of the trading relationship. And from 1 January 2028, the mechanism is proposed to extend downstream, pulling in processed goods well beyond today’s six sectors. See our full CBAM briefing for Thai exporters →

The verification gap — and what it costs

Here is the mechanic that decides whether CBAM is a manageable cost or a compounding penalty. Under the simplified 2026 rules, an importer may declare embedded emissions in one of two ways — and only one of them requires you to have done the work.

Default valuesVerified actual values
Emissions sourceCommission-published defaultsYour own measured data
Third-party verificationNot requiredRequired — accredited verifier
Markup applied+10% in 2026, +20% 2027, +30% from 2028None
Reflects your efficiencyNo — benchmarked against high emittersYes — rewards a cleaner process
Reusable elsewhereNoYes — feeds TSRS, FTSE, customers

The punitive markup is deliberate policy design: defaults are meant to be the expensive option, so that measuring beats guessing. A Thai producer running a genuinely lower-carbon process but declaring on defaults pays for emissions it never emitted — and pays an escalating premium on top, rising to 30% from 2028.

The compliance perimeter also moved. The old €150-per-shipment trigger has been replaced by a 50-tonne annual threshold per importer across CBAM goods; below it, reporting, declaration and certificate obligations fall away (electricity and hydrogen excepted). Above it, the penalties are real: €100 per tonne CO₂e for inaccurate or missing declarations, and €300–500 per tonne for importing without authorisation.

Thailand has no EU-recognised verifier yet

This is the pressure point specific to Thailand. Verification of actual values must be performed by a verifier accredited by a national accreditation body inside the EU — and Thai industry is still lobbying for EU recognition of domestic accredited verifiers. In practice that means the queue for legitimate verification is long, the capacity is European, and the lead time is not something you can compress in the fortnight before a declaration is due.

Which makes the preparatory work — the part you can control — the whole game:

1
Product-level MRV
Measurement, reporting and verification built at the installation and product line, not estimated top-down from group totals.
2
Precursor traceability
Emissions cascade through inputs. Your suppliers’ data becomes your declared figure — map it before a verifier asks.
3
TGO-certified baseline
CFO for the organisation, CFP for the product. A recognised national baseline your data can be reconciled against.
4
Verification-ready file
Methodology, boundaries, emission factors and evidence assembled so an accredited verifier can sign rather than reconstruct.

Thailand already has the domestic machinery for the third step. The Thailand Greenhouse Gas Management Organization (TGO) certifies both the Carbon Footprint for Organization (CFO) — total tCO₂e across Scopes 1, 2 and 3 for a reporting year — and the Carbon Footprint of Product (CFP), the life-cycle figure for a single product under ISO 14067. CFP is the granularity CBAM actually speaks. How TGO CFO certification works →

One carbon dataset, three audiences

Now the part that changes the economics of doing this properly. The emissions dataset you build for CBAM is not single-purpose. Three separate audiences are asking for versions of the same numbers in the same reporting year:

EU customs

Product-level embedded emissions, verified, to avoid default values and their escalating markup.

Thai SEC · TSRS

SET50 report climate-first under IFRS S2 for FY2027 — Scope 1 & 2 with limited assurance, Scope 3 deferred.

FTSE Russell

Scores the Climate Change theme from your public disclosure — Scope 1 & 2 on FTSE methodology, Scope 3 on LSEG’s.

Your customers

EU buyers increasingly require supplier-level carbon data contractually, ahead of the 2028 downstream extension.

Build the inventory once, to a verifiable standard, and it services all four. Build it as a compliance one-off for the border, and you will rebuild it twice more — with three sets of numbers that do not reconcile, which is the worst outcome of all. Read how TGO carbon data feeds an FTSE score →

Why an unverified number scores as a missing one

Here is the detail most boards still miss, and it is the one closest to our own work. From 2026, FTSE Russell scores SET-listed companies from public disclosure — there is no questionnaire. Its ESG model applies over 300 indicators across pillars and themes, weighted by each company’s exposure; for a Thai exporter in steel, cement or aluminium, the Climate Change theme is high-exposure, which means it carries maximum weight in the pillar score.

And FTSE reads that disclosure in English. Your Thai 56-1 One Report satisfies the SEC. It is not the version a rater reads. The English edition does.

So a carbon number can fail twice over, for two different reasons, in the same year. Unverified at the border, it is replaced by a default value and marked up. Undisclosed — or disclosed only in Thai, or rendered into English with drifting terminology so that “ขอบเขตการรายงาน” and the reporting boundary it defines no longer match the figure beside them — it is a number the rater cannot follow. Not weak — unreadable. A rater cannot award points for a number it cannot read, and cannot reconcile a boundary it cannot follow. Where ESG translation risk actually bites →

What SET-listed exporters should do this quarter

The paid phase is live, the first TSRS reporting year (FY2027) is one year out, and the FY2026 disclosure that FTSE will score is being written now. Four moves that pay for themselves across all three:

Key takeaways
  • Establish product-level MRV for every CBAM-covered line, and map the precursor cascade through your suppliers before a verifier requests it.
  • Get the baseline TGO-certified — CFO for the organisation, CFP under ISO 14067 for the product — so your declared figures rest on a recognised national methodology.
  • Make Scope 1 & 2 limited-assurance ready now; TSRS requires it from FY2027, and the same evidence file serves CBAM verification.
  • Publish the numbers in a terminology-locked English edition, clause-mapped to the Thai One Report, so the figure FTSE scores is the figure your SEC filing states.

See what your English disclosure is actually scoring

From 2026 FTSE Russell scores SET-listed companies from public English disclosure — no questionnaire. Run the free Gap Audit and see, theme by theme, where your carbon story is losing points it has already earned.

Run the free Gap Audit

CBAM has done Thai exporters an unintended favour. It has attached a price to imprecise carbon accounting, and in doing so made the business case for measuring properly self-evident — a case that sustainability teams have been making without a spreadsheet to point at for years. The companies that respond by building one verifiable carbon dataset, and then publishing it in an English edition that survives contact with a rater, will find they have solved the border, the regulator and the index in a single piece of work. Start with TSRS S1 & S2 readiness → · Track every 2026 deadline →

Sources: European Commission (CBAM definitive regime and 2026 simplification rules); The Nation / Kasikorn Research Centre (฿28bn estimate; Federation of Thai Industries Steel Industry Group); LSEG / FTSE Russell ESG Data Model methodology; IFRS Foundation & Thai SEC (TSRS / IFRS S2 phase-in); TGO (CFO and CFP certification schemes).

Before your next disclosure cycle

See where your English edition is losing FTSE points.

A free Gap Audit maps your published English disclosure against FTSE Russell’s 14 themes — and shows exactly which gaps are quietly costing you points, index inclusion and investor attention.

ISO 17100 · NDA from the first email · 100% in-house Bangkok bench
Facebook
Twitter
LinkedIn
WhatsApp
Get Free Quote

Answers

Frequently asked questions

What does CBAM's paid phase mean for Thai exporters?
In CBAM's definitive phase, EU importers must surrender certificates corresponding to the embedded carbon in covered goods, which turns emissions into a direct cost on trade with the EU. Thai exporters of affected products, such as steel, aluminium, cement, and fertilizers, need verified emissions data to avoid default values that can overstate their carbon and their cost.
Why do Thai exporters need verified emissions data for CBAM?
CBAM requires reporting of the actual embedded emissions of exported goods, and where verified installation-level data is missing, less favourable default values may apply. Producing credible, well-documented emissions figures, and translating the supporting documentation accurately, helps exporters demonstrate their real carbon footprint to EU customers.
How does Othello support CBAM documentation?
Othello helps Thai exporters prepare and translate the carbon and emissions documentation that EU importers request under CBAM, working across the English and Thai versions both sides need. This includes aligning the underlying carbon footprint data with the format and terminology that CBAM reporting requires.
FTSE 2026 PlaybooksFree ESG disclosure guides
Chat on LINEแอดไลน์ · ตอบใน 1 ชม.
Add Othello ESG on LINE (QR code)
แอดไลน์ · Add us on LINE
Scan to chat with Othello ESG on LINE — a reply within one business hour, under NDA from the first message.
Open LINE →
Recognised & delivered Credited in DLA Piper × UK PACT × DCCE’s carbon-pricing report · SET JUMP+ Advisory Pool listed advisor · FTSE Russell 4.0/5.0 delivered · ISO 17100 certified
Get a 1-hour quote →

Research & Reports

Free Tools

ISSB Training

· YouTube
Free tools & research State of ESG Disclosure· ESG Rating Check· FTSE 2026 Playbooks· Regulation Radar· Greenwashing Checker